- BEST OVERALL SHOW
- You Can't Take It With You
- Seussical: The Musical
- Yes, Virginia, There is a Santa Claus
- Steel Magnolias
- Godspell
- BEST PLAY, NON-MUSICAL
- You Can't Take It With You
- Yes, Virginia, There is a Santa Claus
- Steel Magnolias
- BEST PLAY, MUSICAL
- Seussical: The Musical
- Godspell
- BEST MUSIC DIRECTOR
- Caroline Mansfield - Godspell
- Eddie Carney - Seussical: The Musical
- BEST CHOREOGRAPHER
- Sarah E. Ruple - Godspell
- Heather Hoffman - Suessical: The Musical
- BEST ACTRESS
- Kaila Taton JoJo "Seussical"
- Chelsea Cooper Disciple "Godspell"
- Tari Bergoine M'Lynn "Steel Magnolias"
- Anna Davis Jenny Sycamore "You Can't Take It With You"
- Kate Wright Comella Andrea Borland "Yes, Virginia..."
- BEST ACTOR
- David Fox Frank Church "Yes, Virginia..."
- Brian Crowley The Cat in the Hat "Seussical"
- Geoff Griggs Grandpa Vanderhoff "You Can't Take It With You"
- John Kolar Jesus "Godspell"
- BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS
- Christine Bohn Alice Sycamore "You Can't Take It With You"
- Kristin Nezband Gertrude "Seussical: The Musical"
- Civia Wiesner Evie O"Hanlon "Yes, Virginia..."
- Caitlin Sandham Shelby "Steel Magnolias"
- Jenny Allenby Disciple "Godspell"
- BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR
- Matt Mortenson Tony Kirby "You Can't Take It With You"
- Pete Percassi Horton "Seussical: The Musical"
- John Kolar James O'Hanlon "Yes, Virginia..."
- Mike Bollinger Judas "Godspell"
- BEST FEATURED ACTRESS
- Jacinda Sandness-Griggs Essie "You Can't Take It With You"
- Marylin Young Mrs. Mayor "Seussical: The Musical"
- Mayim Hamblen Virginia O'Hanlon "Yes, Virginia..."
- Allison Lehr Annelle "Steel Magnolias"
- Julie Douglass Disciple "Godspell"
- BEST FEATURED ACTOR
- Mark Cipra Kolenkov "You Can't Take It With You"
- Tom Jessup Mayor "Seussical: The Musical"
- Mark Miloro Edward P. Mitchell "Yes, Virginia..."
- Chad Duwe Disciple "Godspell"
- BEST DIRECTOR
- Ann Hedger - You Can't Take It With You
- Brendan Sandham - Seussical: The Musical
- Karen Porter - Yes, Virginia, There is a Santa Claus
- Brint Learned - Steel Magnolias
- Michael Breeze - Godspell
- BEST COSTUME DESIGN
- Kerry Allenby - You Can't Take It With You
- Kerry Allenby - Seussical: The Musical
- Karen Porter - Yes, Virginia, There is a Santa Claus
- Caitlin Sandham - Steel Magnolias
- Kerry Allenby - Godspell
- BEST SCENIC DESIGN / SET
- Brendan Sandham - You Can't Take It With You
- Amy Quist - Seussical: The Musical
- Anthony Nedelman - Yes, Virginia, There is a Santa Claus
- Brad Rasch - Steel Magnolias
- Michael Breeze - Godspell
- BEST TECHNICAL DESIGN - LIGHTS
- Pat Fagan - You Can't Take It With You
- Steve Shack - Seussical: The Musical
- Pat Fagan, Jeff Lelko - Yes, Virginia, There is a Santa Claus
- Pat Fagan, Jeff Lelko - Steel Magnolias
- Jeff Lelko - Godspell
- BEST TECHNICAL DESIGN - SOUND
- Emilie Schmidt - You Can't Take It With You
- Clayton Sandham- Seussical: The Musical
- Phil Lewandowski Yes, Virginia, There is a Santa Claus
- Clayton Sandham - Steel Magnolias
- Phil Lewandowski - Godspell